It is a contentious issue that has garnered a lot of media attention in the past. What are an individual's rights when approached by a member of law enforcement? Estevan's Police Chief, Paul Ladouceur, was in Regina yesterday outlining that very subject.  

"The purpose of the meeting yesterday," explained Estevan's Police Chief, Paul Ladouceur, "was the Saskatchewan Police Commision was looking to do a public release on the new contact interview policy that has been drafted. They wanted to let the public know that this policy is in place."

"The purpose of the policy, quite frankly, is somewhat forward thinking. The Commision and the Chiefs of Police in this province were concerned because of what we have been witnessing across the country, a lot of dialogue and a lot of concerns what's commonly referred to as street checks and has been referred to in the past as carding."

"The idea of this was to put a policy in place that ensures that when the police engage with the public, that they have a formalized approach in how they're going out doing that to ensure that there's that balance between protecting people's rights and freedoms and allowing the police to do the important work that they have to do in their communities across the province."

So what does this mean for you?

"If an officer is walking down the street and approaches you. There are generally three types of contacts primarily that the police will have with the community. One of those contacts would simply be good community policing. Where a police officer is driving down the street and happens to see a child and stops to say hi and talks about the weather and it's just general conversation. Generally, people don't mind engaging in that, they're not asking them for information or anything like that."

"The other one that is very clear is where a police officer has reasonable cause to detain somebody or reasonable grounds to arrest somebody in which case the member of the public is required to identify to the officer upon arrest."

This would also fall under the example of when an officer pulls over a car for a speeding or other type of traffic offence and asks your name. In this situation, you are required to prove your name to that officer. 

He added that while those two situations are fairly cut and dried, there's another type of contact that is a little less black and white. 

"Where it becomes a little more complex is those ones in between where if a police officer is driving through an industrial area at two in the morning, none of the businesses are open at that time and they observe some people walking down the street or between the buildings in the middle of the night where reasonably you wouldn't expect somebody to be. Is it reasonable, would the public support the police wanting to talk to those people?"

"Those people may just be walking through and taking a shortcut to get home but they may be looking to do a break and enter."

"What we're saying in those situations is, those checks are voluntary. If an officer asks, "can I get your name?" And the person says,"I don't want to give you my name." That's the individual's right. They don't have to do that. Generally, people do comply. If a person chooses to walk away, they have the right to do so."

He used another example of a person standing on a bridge.

"Is it a case where they're just taking in the view or is that person contemplating self-harm? Would it be prudent for the police officer to stop and have a conversation with that individual."

"It's one of those cases where the lightbulb goes off and they say something's not right here. But it doesn't equate to the fact that there is reasonable ground to arrest an individual. It's one of those things where the officer's senses are telling him something doesn't seem right with this situation. And in those cases, what are the rights of the individual and what are the rights of the police officer. Now, having something formalized that hold some level of accountability on how we'll proceed in those situations and educates the public."

"The goal is both for the police officers that are on the streets and the general public to be well informed of what the rights and the rules are."

"I think the majority of the public would expect the police officer to stop, engage, and have these conversations where something is telling the officer that something doesn't seem right."

Much has been made that these so-called street checks are racially motivated. Ladouceur acknowledges that officers are human too with biases just like the regular public. 

"We read the odd time about an officer who messes up or does something wrong. I think Chiefs hold their members to a high degree of accountability. There is discipline that can be issued through the Police Act for officers who don't comply with the policy."

"Years ago in policing, were there police officers who would stop and ask people for their name and their address and what they were up to for no reason at all? Sure there was. Policing changes and it evolves over the years and I think we have to look at what are we doing better than we did years ago. We can't change the past, we can only change how we proceed in the future."

"Obviously police shouldn't be going out and arbitrarily stopping people, especially based on race or gender or anything like that. Certainly, as a Chief of Police, I would never tolerate that from our members."

The new policy was drafted by the commision in consultation with the Saskatchewan Federation of Police Officers as well as the Saskatchewan Association of Chiefs of Police and various stakeholders. 

A full copy of the policy can be found here.

More Local News

Federal Budget 2019: Local MP Dr. Robert Kitchen

Souris-Moose Mountain MP Doctor Robert Kitchen didn’t sugarcoat his opinion on the federal budget delivered in Ottawa on Tuesday. “This is all staged to be a cover-up,” Kitchen said, alluding to the…

Wildlife Federation Voices Displeasure over Office Closures

Last week the Ministry of Environment announced the closure of 19 field offices, including the one here in Estevan. The decision was a result of budgte cuts and will impact 19 jobs, three of which…

Some Results From Last Nights EPS Board Meeting

The EPS held there police board meeting last night and while there was nothing extraordinary there were a few items of note. The police noted that there was a slight decrease in property crimes in…

Provincial Budget Investing In Intersection Safety

The 2019-20 Budget is balanced and is providing support for mental health and for vulnerable families to increasing funding to classrooms and improvements to highway safety. To improve safety at…

Street Closure Due To Sewer Replacement

There is a road closure in the Energy City today. Safety Coordinator with the City Of Estevan Helen Fornwald, "The City of Estevan would like to advise the public, that the 10 hundred block of Valley…

The Estevan Army Cadet Corp Holding 102nd Anniversary Vimy Remembered In April

The No.2901 Estevan Elks Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry Royal Canadian Army Cadet Corp will be hosting the 102nd Anniversary Vimy Remembered Presentation in April. Its a way for the…

Rock Your Socks Off For Down Syndrome Awareness

On World Down Syndrome Day, Thursday 21 March 2019, the Down Syndrome community is calling upon every person with Down syndrome to tell the world to “leave no one behind”. Kala Wock local resident on…

Recreational Needs Assessment

The announcement was made by the City of Estevan yesterday about a new Recreational Needs Assessment that has already started to gather information from our community about what our city needs moving…

City in Holding Pattern Awaiting Carbon Tax Impact

Even the most devoted fans of April Fools Day aren't looking forward to the first of the month this year as the federally instituted carbon tax looms. The exact nature of the tax's impact on…

Provincial Budget 2019: First Look

A balanced budget, as promised. Saskatchewan Finance Minister Donna Harpauer delivered the 2019-20 budget in the Legislature Wednesday afternoon, posting a $34 million surplus. The budget includes… is Estevan's only source for community news and information such as weather and classifieds.

Search the Biz Guide